Analysis & Commentary Rick on 31 Mar 2008 11:09 pm
There Goes Another One …
Dave Kehr reports (via Radar) that after 30 years, David Ansen (below right) is leaving Newsweek, taking a handsome
buy-out offered to him by the magazine. Hard times have befallen the newsweeklies, with cost-cutting moves common. Ansen told Anne Thompson that “It was a good deal . . . They didn’t want me to leave, which put me in a nice bargaining position.” Unlike most of the other 110 staffers who took the deal, Ansen will stay until the end of the year reviewing films, then an additional year as a contributing editor.
The departure of Ansen marks a growing concern that the professional, in-print film critic is an endangered species. Writes Thompson:
The current harsh publishing climate has been hard on film critics. Gone from newspaper staff reviewer ranks are The Chicago Reader’s Jonathan Rosenbaum, Newsday’s John Anderson, The Village Voice’s Nathan Lee, The New York Daily News’ Jami Bernard and Jack Mathews, The Chicago Tribune’s Michael Wilmington and The Atlanta Journal Constitution’s Eleanor Ringel Gillespie. Some have retired and some have been pushed out. “It is scary; they’re letting a lot of good people go these days,” said Ansen. “It’s like a return to the hard old days when I was growing up when anybody could be a movie critic, and they’d take somebody off the sports desk.”
I well remember Ansen’s reviews — back when we subscribed to Newsweek, that is. And the past-tense “subscribed” is the key. I no longer subscribe to Newsweek or any other newsweekly in large part because I can read high-quality, professional criticism — and news and sports and opinion — for free, on the World Wide Web. Not to mention the scads of fair-to-middlin’ to very good amateur critics and bloggers.
What bigger disincentive to pay for something than the fact that you can get it without charge? Not a particularly robust business model.
[There's a great ongoing discussion of this over at Scanners]





















on 01 Apr 2008 at 2:43 pm # Marilyn
I think it’s a little disingenuious of Ansen to bemoan the fact that “anyone” can be a film critic today. In fact, some of our best-known print film critics, including Siskel and Ebert, were reporters who were drafted to fill the critic’s role, and I’m sure Ansen has no small amount of respect for them.
I stopped subscribing to Newsweek (and I had a professional discount that made it practically free for me) when it went tabloid and news-lite in its coverage. I was particularly disturbed by the coverage of Andrew Cunanan’s killing spree and the innuendos it made about the gay community. That was the final straw.
on 01 Apr 2008 at 7:56 pm # Rick
Not to mention, I believe, A.O. Scott.
Yeah, I had a professional discount too … I just gradually kind of lost interest as the mag became weaker and weaker.
on 03 Apr 2008 at 8:47 am # Daniel
Interesting development. I still subscribe to TIME, but they’re certainly backsliding toward a tabloid, too, and they can’t get any sense of how they want to redesign the magazine. I actually still get the NYT on Sundays, too, mostly because I really still do enjoy holding a paper or NYT Mag, if only for the sake of nostalgia.
on 04 Apr 2008 at 7:56 am # Rick
Daniel, I don’t think anybody knows what will work, short of People/Us-style tabloids. It’s really hard, I think, to do a balance, a blend if you will.